Some Cigar Reviews...

Joined Aug 2004
6 Posts | 0+
NYMFC
Romeo and Julieta Celestiales Finos
Ring gauge 46 - Cigar Length 5.2 inches


Picked this up from a box pass. Wrapper was a milk chocolate color. The unlit aroma was a little on the sweet side. The cigar was in a box pass, so it had some minor defects, but nothing that would potentially derail the smoking experience.

Clipped the cigar and torched the foot. Initial draw was ok. Not too loose, but a little looser than I like it.

First third had a very bready flavor to it. It took a while for the flavor to come out due to the foot of this particular vitola, but when it did, it opened up nicely.

Second third included some very creamy notes, almost like a soft caramel like aftertaste on the pallate. A "tingle" so to speak of spice on the pallate as well, but very muted. The aroma of the smoke was very pleasing. It was a very toasty aroma and added to the flavorful experience.

In the last third, the flavors opened up even more with the caramel, bread, and a hint of coffee (with milk) flavor coming through on every draw.

This cigar was very easy on the pallate. It was a very smooth, relaxing, almost laid back type of smoke that didn't want to do too much on purpose.

A very good morning cigar or a lazy sunday afternoon cigar.

2) Romeo and Julieta Churchill - 2001
Ring gauge 47 - Cigar Length 6.8 inches


I received this from a trade and decided to light it up after a month in the humi.

The cigar had a chocolate brown wrapper with a few veins. The wrapper was a bit brittle, but nothing crazy. I keep my humi at about 64%.

Pre light aroma had a hint of sweetness with some cedar. Clipped, torched and took a draw. Initial impression was of a very mellow, almost mild cigar.

First third was mild with some woodsy, cedar notes and a faint hint of sweetness. The draw was a bit loose for my liking, but it was bearable.

Second third began to pick up a slight nutty taste, almost like burnt peanuts. Still a very woodsy, cedary, mild - medium smoke at this point.

Last third was a mellow combination of all of the above. The nutty taste became a little more prevalent along with the cedary, woodsy taste and aroma.

I wouldn't call it an "elegant" smoke like a fundadore. It's more of like a "relaxed" smoke. Flavorful, but not strong and overwhelming.

A very, very good cigar.

3)RyJ Robusto EL - 2001
Got this in a trade a while back from a good friend. Here's a lil' somethin somethin on it.

Size= 5x50

Wrapper: Nice dark chocolate wrapper with a few veins on it. I've had it in my 'dor at about 62%rh for over a month resting up. Pre light aroma was sweet and once clipped, had a good draw; not too tight, not too loose.

Torched the foot and then lit it with some wooden matches. Initial draw was a bit harsh ( I had the torch a little TOO close to the foot while torching..my bad..lol), but then settled nicely. The smoke had a very strong sweet chocolate smell and the first few draws confirmed this. Very heavy chocolate, cocoa notes on the palate. No spice, but it was a "heavy" smoke, so to speak. This cigar was meant to be smoked s-l-o-w-l-y..and, well I did..lol

There was a slight run towards the 2nd third of the cigar, but it quickly corrected itself. The finish was intense. There was no lack of flavor in this little sucker. Very smoky cigar, as every draw produced good flavor and a good volume of smoke.

The cigar finished well...well into my thumb..lol. Nubbed it and then lamented smoking it..lol

Enjoyed this cigar very much. Long, intense finish on the palate. I still tasted chocolate for about an hour after finishing smoking.

Great cigar.
 
Yes indeed, Red1922, Special Secret Assistant To The Secretary of Homeboyland Security graces us with his presence and a detailed review of three cigars.

For those of you not familiar with various cigar related acronyms, that last cigar was a Jen(ifer) U. Wine Kyoobin Romeo Y Julieta Edicion Limitada 2001, and that's one baaaaaaaaaaad cigahhhhhh.

The others are from the Non-Cuban Romeo y Julieta line, the Churchill being a favorite of mine. Thanks to Red1922 for joining up and pitching in.

Folks, listen up. I have made mention in the past of how, although being Moderator of this forum, I am not nearly as qualified as certain other folks that I knew at "another web site" to really "carry" this forum in the sense of providing the ultimate in terms of knowledge and experience. Many of the folks that have recently logged on to greet me and pitch in are indeed the ones who can provide us with that experts touch. I thank them for their participation and urge those of you truly wishing for deep, intense, cigar related education to read carefully and fully, because you will learn much from them.
 
Below is a review I did at CA online a few months back after receiving three free Padilla Cigars (Hybrids) from the owner of the company - Ernesto Padilla to sample prior to their release. It was such an unexpected treat that I thought I would share the review with cigar lovers here. These are fabulous smokes!

OK, I had an opportunity to smoke the Churchill last night. My My My! First let me say that this is almost the perfect sized Churchill…. Nice length and a ring gauge of about 47 or 48. Not a tree trunk, but a Corona-plus ring gauge with a Churchill reach.. I’m guessing that this is the Nicaraguan line. Wrapper to light to be Cameroon, leaf was a little heavy in vein, not that this made any difference as the construction was again superb. Flat gorgeous construction, end cap nicely done as well. Whoever rolls these puppies should be teaching rolling classes. True artisan craftsmanship. Smooth draw, even burn. Gorgeous ash - very Davidoff like in its light gray flakiness and consistency.

This is a very interesting cigar. It starts right out the gate with a fair amount of spiciness, like a softer OpusX. This is also a full bodied smoke, but it takes on different characteristics as you burn down the stogie. This was not real subtle either. About half way into the gar, it took on a little additional smoothness (which is not what I expect here, usually it gets harsher the farther down the stick you go). Much more ‘grassy’ undertones (yet still spicy with lots of nutty flavors), which I would expect from a Honduran cigar. The draw is just lusty, delivers rich flavors. Hints of cream maybe, earth and light coffee were noted. Balanced, flavorful, full bodied and really intriguing. I keep finding myself looking at this cigar, exhaling and wondering just when it was that I got beamed up to the Nirvana Cigar Planet, where everyone smokes Ambrosia Leaf all the time made by reincarnated Cuban guys who have been rolling for over 400 years. It was that nice. Burned my fingers trying to extract every last bit of pleasure from this gem.

I’m hooked. I am now a Padilla stogie hair-lipped, hunched back junkie. One more to go tonight, the Torpedo, hoping I have saved the best for last. After that I’ll be digging in my ash trays looking for just one more Padilla Hybrid fix, before I start chewing my fingers off and quivering on the deck hoping to extract just a little relief from some common Fuente Don Carlos or something… (of course I’m joking, I love Fuentes… but I have a New Favorite methinks) Can’t wait for these to hit the shelf, and wear the hell out of the newness this had brought to my 15 year stogie habit. Kudos Mr. Padilla. You have made a believer out of me. I should get paid for all of this rambling…. Wait I DID. I got three free superstogies….. :D
 
Actually Bloof, that RyJ Churchill is a Cuban as well :wink:
 
OOPS!!!! Thanks for clearing that up, Red1922.

See folks, I told you these guys knew their cigars, and Red1922's probably never going to forgive me for even suggesting, much less stating that he would smoke a Non-Cuban RyJ Churchill. :cry:
 
Actually, never had the NC version of the Churchill. Only had the Bully's from the NC line.

That being said....who says there's anything to forgive about bro?


More reviews to come!
 
Padilla cigars

Hello Everyone,

I wanted to introduce myself. My name is Ernesto Padilla maker of Padilla cigars.

I want to thank Fernando for the invitation to come visit this great forum.

Thank you for the great review on the cigars. Altough we received an outstanding review from Ciagr Aficionado a 90 and 91 rating and also in the new cigar magazine CigarWise we got a B+ What 's really great is to hear great feed back from everyday cigar smokers.

Thank you for the invitation to visit the site. Please feel fre to visit mine at http://www.padillacigars.com the cigars will be in select stores across America shortly.

Regards,
Ernesto Padilla
Padilla cigars
305-362-4480
 
WOW!!! A cousin in the cigar business!!! Who knew??? Whenever I see my last name I get nervous. I hear most Padillas are related, but don't worry, just because that Al Qaeda guy in Chicago has our name too, he ain't one of us! Boy, did my father take some kidding about that, since he's Jose Padilla, too, but he's 79 and this other guy is in his 30's.

No way he could be my father. I'm almost 48, so no way, right? :duh:

At any rate, welcome to the site. We sure do need knowledgeable and experienced cigar people around here. And a Padilla, too!!! So Primo, how about ten boxes of this and five boxes of that for a long lost cousin, no? I'll call my father down on the farm in Cabo Rojo and have him send you some mangos and guinea hens.

Or would you prefer a whole cow? :D
 
Ernesto - thank you for taking the time out to join our forum. You are definitely a welcomed addition to our group.
 
Great to see you here, Ernesto!!

I still have the torpedo sampler sitting in my humidor. I'm going to get to them, very very soon!!

I'm very excited and anxious about giving them a try!
 
Ernesto... ditto the above. Hope they are a bit friendlier here than Savona can be at CA (??!??)

Your cigars are first rate - my new favorites!! :D
 
Don't worry; I too have dealt with Savona and his heavy handed approach to moderating. That will not happen on this forum.