Hello there Cowboy!
Well, I'll try to recommend a few things to you:
Have you tried the Jim Beam Black?
Evan Williams makes a Single Barrel Bourbon, you will probably find bottles from 1996 right now, that typically rates pretty well too.
I'll get flamed for this, But I like Maker's Mark Bourbon, and for $20-$25 I think it's a good bargain as well....
You will see a fella named Bloofington chime in here in a few minutes with his 2 cents as well......
Don't listen to him, he's only tried something on the order of 77 Bourbons....( he's a lightweight.... :roll: )
Oh, and welcome to the forum!