Everything depends on the situation one may be in. Especially when talking about Cigar etiquette...
If I am in a very nice restaurant or lounge, I will use a cutter for the sake of being "Proper" I tend to always use matches though, since that is more traditional than a lighter, not as easy but a lot of fun...
Malone, you seem to really enjoy the traditional ways when it comes to cigar smoking...
Even though cigar smoking is all about the individual, there really are no wrongs, with the exception of manners when it comes to cigars, especially in Europe. A lot like manners at a dinner table, there are manners when it comes to smoking....
i.e.
You never gesture with a cigar in your hand....
You never speak with a cigar in your mouth...
You never let another man light your cigar for you, especially while holding a flame in front of you, but it is okay to light a cigar for a woman. (Traditional remember)
You never leave the band on....(Ironic to me, because it was the Europeans, a Dutch man who invented the band in the first place to make his cigars stand out from rest, or another theory, is that it was to protect the gentleman's white dinner gloves from getting tobacco stains).
There are more but that's the idea...
There are proper ways and personal ways to do everything....and cigar smoking is included in that
If I'm in the yard I tend to light the cigar w/out lighting the foot, as opposed to when I'm in a settled environment I won't even put it to my lips until it is completely glowing, and after I let it sit a minute to cool down....
I'm ranting but
That's my two cents anyway....