Magus Gran Magus

Joined May 2004
965 Posts | 0+
Tombstone, AZ
Got a couple of these at Tim's sit-down back in October.

Had the first when I first got back home.

Decent construction, a tad too much glue on the wrapper. No big deal. Had some burn issues, and the wrapper kept opening up. Figured it might be from the travel, I'd let the other sit. The taste was on the bland side, potent, almost overwhelming tobacco taste and aftertaste.

OK, the other has been sitting two months. Once out of the cellphane, I took a look at the construction. Something I'd never seen in 26 years of cigars. On the side of the cap, a hole. Not a beetle hole, a gaping wound. Well, a wrapper flaw can be overlooked, but whoever rolled it, smeared glue all over the cap, as to cover the hole. Fred Sanford would use less Bondo on his truck. I cut it anyway. Wrapper just came undone. I tried my best to salvage it. Looking back, I have no idea why. Lit it anyway. Now the foot is unwrapping. Being stubborn and dilligent, I kept going. Made it just over 1/2 through, but when I hit the taste of dry hay, I had to give up.

After research, I see these are going for about $150/box of 25. Don't bother. These were free, and I still feel like I got taken.
 
Maybe that is the reason you got them for free, they were lemons

We need a cigarfax.com to research the cigars history :lol:
 
Sorry to hear that Colonel. I got these from Paul prior to the SC Sit Down in October. I'm sure we both agree that we appreciate him sending the cigars for us to try. Since you've done just that, and found that they aren't "your cup of tea", I can assume you won't be in the market for any in the future.



At the Sit Down in May, Paul sent some of these that were in a maduro wrapper. I enjoyed them very much. They did not fall apart and the construction was very good. Maybe the batch that he sent most recently was not constructed as well. I really don't know, but cigar comments like yours are valid. They reflect what you thought about the particular cigar. I appreciate your comments, just as I appreciate Paul going to the trouble to send them to us.
 
CastleCrest said:
are these PMag cigars?

Meaning from Paul Magus creator of Pinar?

Yes. Paul has sent cigars to us to pass out for 2 of our 3 SC Sit Downs, and I sincerely appreciate them. Cigars are like women; every one out there won't suit everyone! :lol: