The - Salt Test 101

Jun 2005
2,078
McHenry, IL
Thats a good outlook. Cigars are about relaxation not frustration. I'm still anal though and no amount of cigars is gonna help that.
 
Apr 2006
1,740
on the grass
i hope this isnt an accidental repost.... my computer is doing strange things.

i finally broke down and got a digital hygrometer. It is being salt tested as i type this. My dial works just fine and is being moved to my 5 vegas humi and the digital one is going in the main humidor.
I only got the digital because it has an alarm for the RH being too low or too high.

... plus it was on sale for 50% off at my local shop.
 
Sep 2006
307
Morgantown, WV or Fort Lee, NJ
Any thoughts on why some of the digital hygrometers say not to salt test them? Has anyone had a problem with their digital after a salt test. I've just been trusting the digital on its own.
 
Apr 2006
1,740
on the grass
ummm... they think you could spill the water? iduno.

i dont see any reason why you shouldnt be able to.
 
Jun 2005
2,078
McHenry, IL
I think it's because salt is conductive and it could mess with the circuitry. I for one haven't had any problems with the three I've tested.
 
Jul 2006
285
Chicago burbs
Here's a question I've been dieing to ask, but been afraid to, so here goes:

Let's say I have three different digital hygrometers; one from Radio Shack, on Don Savatore, and one generic. If I lay all three side by side, anywhere in my house lets say, and all three read the exact same RH, is it fair to say that they are accurate? My logic being: what are the chances that three hygrometers, from three separate vendors could be EXACTLY the same percentage off?

If I salt-test these, and they are all exactly equally off, would it not be more likely that the salt test is wrong? Or that I'm doing the salt test wrong?
 
Oct 2005
2,364
Lost in translation
There is nothing wrong with the test. It is scientific fact and works as long as you are performing it correctly.

Have you tested your hygrometers?
 
Jul 2006
285
Chicago burbs
I suppose I meant to infer that "I" was doing the test wrong, I have no doubts about the science behind it.

Anyway, I'm doing the test again today. I took the cap from a Gatorade bottle, Kosher salt, and distilled water. I haven't been able to get the mixture to a true "paste" form, more of a slush. Not sure if that matters, but I'll check it in 24 hours and see what happens.
 
Feb 2015
31
Jackson TN USA
*bump*

Two things:

First, the salt-test calibration can be done using ordinary table salt, including iodized salt. The sodium chloride is what matters, any other ingredient is in such small amount that it won't significantly affect the 75% RH result. (You can also use a Boveda 75% pack; Boveda even sells a kit that includes a small pack and a plastic bag.)

Second, with digital hygrometers you always want to make sure you have a fresh battery in the hygrometer before you start. If a previously-reliable digital hygrometer in a usually stable humidor gives an unusual reading, replace the battery and recalibrate; odds are, the problem is just a weak battery rather than an actual problem maintaining RH.