The Great Dumboni Strikes Again!!! From the files of . . .

Joined Sep 2003
9K Posts | 0+
Puerto Rico/NYC
Why don'tcha try lookin' under yer nose, you jerk?

From the files of . . .

the answers to our problems usually lie right in front of our faces.

From the files of . . .

Wellll, would ya look at what Ah dun foun' in mah own backyard!!!

:duh: :duh: :duh:

From the files of . . .

what a freakin' maroon.

:duh: :roll: :duh: :?

Recently, I was down in the Astor Place section of Lower Manhattan. This is in the 8th Street area as the East Side meets the West Side, where Broadway does yet another crossover, and the NYU girls are lookin' hot n' hippie-ish still, despite the fact that the 60's are over.

Well, I had known peripherally that there was good liquor store action down there, and had even glanced around at both of the big stores within a block of each other, one on Broadway, the other, Astor Wines on a side street, which is in fact Astor Place itself.

I happened to be in the area recently headed for a client's apartment, and thought that even though both of these places were obviously huge for a New York liquor store, no way they would have competitive prices. After all, I'm not going to find anything competitive with my favorite web sites. I'm fortunate to have found a couple of midtown stores with competitive prices on one or two items. What kind of selection could these guys probably have, and what would their selection be?

Well, after talking to my client's husband about my irrepressible nature of being . . .

In Search of . . .

fine bourbon and rye, he said not to leave without checking out both stores. While he doesn't know the bourbon/rye arena, he knows wine, and gave both stores a big thumbs up. I went back and started looking in the huge window displays seeing a wide variety of bourbon and rye products and some ridiculously low prices on a couple of favorites. I did note that they were both running sales, and the prices were below what I would find at my favorite internet sites, except when they run big sales, and that's not often.

I was shocked by the low prices in fact, and amused by other things. I went inside both stores, quite convenient due to the close proximity. One had something I recently purchased at Binny's for $19.99 (Kentucky Vintage) for the same price :shock: , while another store had it for $31.99 :mrgreen: . Both had Knob Creek for the astoundingly good price of $19.99. Both had very good selections, with Astor Wines winning the selection battle, coming in at "excellent" in my estimation. On many items they were within a dollar or so of each other, on other items far apart, like the Kentucky Vintage example above.

Another example was the Van Winkle Family Reserve 13 year old rye, with Astor Wines selling it for $35.99 and the other place for $44.99. :dunno:

On that trip at Astor Wines I found and purchased a bottle of Old Potrero Straight Rye Whiskey for a "walk-out price" of $76.03. On another trip I purchased a bottle of Baker's, No. 9 on my list for the shockingly low walk-out price of $30.40. With taxes on booze costing less than shipping charges, and prices and selection being what they are at both of these places, my access to a wide selection and competitive prices has suddenly been blown wide open.

A gentleman at Astor Wines told me that the current sale is running until the end of the month and that they have a sale every month. Very interesting. The Old Potrero product that I purchased is in fact the one I have been eagerly . . .

In Search Of . . .

and recent research has finalized my knowledge on this line. A post on the Old Potrero products is upcoming to clear any confusion, provide some direction and advise on my experience.
 
Here Bloofington I'm sort of forgetful - been meaning to send you in here for 6+ months - but then again I also thought you liked /prefered doing busines via mail.

Here's a catch for the day - (HER) name is LeNell, and get a load of her "toll free" number. Is that a coincidence or what? :idea:

LeNell's Ltd: a Wine & Spirit Boutique
416 Van Brunt Street b/t Coffey & Van Dyke, Brooklyn NY 11231
toll free (877) NO-SNOBS | phone (718) 360-0838 | fax (718) 874-2733

http://www.lenells.com/selections/whiskey.php
 
Unbeatable selection, pretty high prices, and the neighborhood may be questionable, definitely hard to get to. I don't really know much about Brooklyn, so I'll have to check with friends. Definitely a place to consider, especially for the two or three items where the prices aren't that bad. In a case like that, if you can't find it anywhere else, it's worth the trip and effort. Thanks for the tip.
 
Okay, now that I've caught up on some reading and posting, I went back to Hollow Point's link. This lady has perhaps the best bourbon and rye selection I've ever seen, and there are three to five bourbon prices that are good to excellent, with others being anywhere from okay to high. The rye prices are generally excellent. I liked the lady's bio and the atmosphere of the shop, at least as it's conveyed through the tour I took of her web site.

She also gives directions and names the neighborhood. Just as I thought, Red Hook. Some parts of Red Hook you don't want to be caught dead walking through. Actually, that's just what would happen to you in those parts. There are other parts of Red Hook that are just fine. I'm suspecting where LeNell's is located is one of those, otherwise why have such an incredible selection, and informal, down home atmosphere?

The shop is actually pretty convenient since it names the A, C or F trains to Jay Street/Borough Hall in Brooklyn, and then taking a bus. The bus ride can't be all that long, but I definitely wouldn't walk from Jay Street/Borough Hall to her store, because I don't know what I'd pass on the way. Again, I'd have to check with friends who know Brooklyn.

I do know this much. I'm very impressed with what I read once I had a chance to study the web site. I couldn't access AmBack for almost 60 hours, otherwise I would have done this sooner. She has perhaps the best price I've ever seen on my No. 3 bourbon, The Classic Cask 20 year old, the second best price by one penny that one could possibly find on my No. 2 rye, Van Winkle Family Reserve 13 year old, and the second best price by one penny on my No. 2 bourbon, the Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve 20 year old.

Since I believe it would take 30-45 minutes from midtown Manhattan to get there, a trip to LeNell's might be in my near future. Thanks again to Hollow Point for a great tip.

Again, right in my own back yard, :duh: or stated another way, Your American Back Yard. :wink: