List of "must" smokes...

B

Big_Deel

Joined Aug 2005

23 Posts | 0+

• Jul 25, 2006

• #21

Here is a list of my favorites.

Cinco vegas "A" Series
Partagas Black Tubed
Opus X Forbidden X
Fuente Flor Fina 8-5-8
Cusano 18 Paired Maduro
Cusano Corojo 1997
Monetcristo White
La Unica No.200 Maduro

 

T

Tanger

Joined Oct 2005

93 Posts | 0+

Lost in PA

• Jul 25, 2006

• #22

My favorites at the moment

CAO Cx2
CAO Mx2
CAO Soprano
Cusano Corojo 97
Cusano C18
Oliva 'O' Classic

 

C

chrisguinther

Joined Aug 2005

2K Posts | 0+

Gahanna, OH

• Jul 25, 2006

• #23

Padron 64 Principe
Oliva Classic Ole
Perdomo Champagne C
La Flor Dominicana Chiselito Maduro
5 Vegas A Alpha

 

D

double D

Joined Jul 2006

285 Posts | 0+

Chicago burbs

Discussion Starter
• Jul 25, 2006

• #24

Thanks for all the replies. Here's my list. I tried to take one suggestion from each of you. Barring availability, I'm ordering two of each from cigar.com.

Motion123 said:

Cusano 18 Double Conn.

talumn said:

5 Vegas Limitada 2005

iminaquagmire said:

CAO MX2

Capt said:

Fuente Hemmingway Best Seller

dejoro said:

Cusano 18 Paired Maduro

dbrad4d said:

Cusano Corojo 1997 Toro

Cloudy said:

Padron 1964

foodislife said:

Cinco vegas "A" Series

cutter said:

Opus X Double Corona

kuzi16 said:

Punch Gran Puro

vince said:

Hemmingway Masterpiece

Brenda said:

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story

phisherman said:

5 vegas classic

DevilDog723 said:

CAO Soprano


Thanks again.

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

 

D

dbrad4d

Joined Mar 2005

1K Posts | 0+

Alabama

• Jul 25, 2006

• #25

No dude ... you sould have said "OK, here's my list from all your suggestions, now you guys, and lady, send me a couple of the one's you suggested that are on my list".

 

T

talumn

Joined Jan 2006

568 Posts | 0+

New Iberia, La

• Jul 25, 2006

• #26

thats a nice list double d

 

phisherman

Joined Oct 2005

2K Posts | 1+

Lost in translation

• Jul 26, 2006

• #27

dbrad4d said:

No dude ... you sould have said "OK, here's my list from all your suggestions, now you guys, and lady, send me a couple of the one's you suggested that are on my list".

Click to expand...

Dean, you got it all wrong. Once he tries them and figures out that he likes them all, he has to send two to each of the ones we recoemnded to us in appreciation of suggesting the smoke. Double D (that's my nick name too with some people), Pm me and I give you my addy. :twisted: :wink:

 

K

kuzi16

Joined Apr 2006

2K Posts | 1+

on the grass

• Jul 26, 2006

• #28

phisherman said:

dbrad4d said:

No dude ... you sould have said "OK, here's my list from all your suggestions, now you guys, and lady, send me a couple of the one's you suggested that are on my list".

Click to expand...

Dean, you got it all wrong. Once he tries them and figures out that he likes them all, he has to send two to each of the ones we recoemnded to us in appreciation of suggesting the smoke. Double D (that's my nick name too with some people), Pm me and I give you my addy. :twisted: :wink:

Click to expand...

YES!! i like that idea


mmm punch gran puro....

 

phisherman

Joined Oct 2005

2K Posts | 1+

Lost in translation

• Jul 27, 2006

• #29

Maybe I should have suggested a more expensive cigar. I already have a good amount of 5 vegas classics (I like their sticks).

 

D

double D

Joined Jul 2006

285 Posts | 0+

Chicago burbs

Discussion Starter
• Jul 27, 2006

• #30

Ugh, more new guy hazing


I'm having trouble finding most of these so far. Apparently some rare cigar choices, but that's cool. It'll make it even more sweet in the end...

 

B

Barcochris

Joined Feb 2006

2K Posts | 3+

Kelvin's House

• Jul 27, 2006

• #31

I can come up with a couple, want to do a trade?

 

phisherman

Joined Oct 2005

2K Posts | 1+

Lost in translation

• Jul 27, 2006

• #32

double D said:

Ugh, more new guy hazing


I'm having trouble finding most of these so far. Apparently some rare cigar choices, but that's cool. It'll make it even more sweet in the end...

Click to expand...

Call up Donny or Tim with cigar.com and I'm sure they fill be able to get most if not all of these for you and at very good prices.

800-357-9800

 

D

dejoro

Joined Apr 2006

691 Posts | 0+

SE Michigan

• Jul 27, 2006

• #33

Well, now we know anyone who wins a PIF from double D in the future can expect a great package!

I didn't see any DutchMasters or White Owls on the list. :wink:

 

D

DevilDog723

Joined Aug 2005

2K Posts | 0+

Armpit of the world....Al Asad, Iraq

• Jul 27, 2006

• #34

DD,
PM sent.

 

D

double D

Joined Jul 2006

285 Posts | 0+

Chicago burbs

Discussion Starter
• Aug 2, 2006

• #35

Had my first smoke from the "must" list. Just thougt I'd share.

Thanks to a kind gift from dejoro, I tried the Cusano 18 Dbl Conn. I must say I rather enjoyed it. I see its a very popular cigar, but I was a little apprehesive at first as I typically prefer Maduro wrappers. But I can certainly tell now that you all won't steer me wrong. It was quite smooth and full of flavor. It was sort of sweet tasting, reminded me a little of oatmeal and nutmeg for some reason.

Good stuff, I'll definetly be stocking up on these.

 

C

cgar_smoker87

Joined Aug 2006

21 Posts | 0+

Pittsburgh, PA

• Sep 5, 2006

• #36

Here are my favorites in this order:

CAO Italia
Aston VSG
Rocky Patel Sun Grown
MOnte Cristo Platinum
Playboy by Don Diego if I'm in the mood for something mild
St. Luis Rey if poor!

 

D

double D

Joined Jul 2006

285 Posts | 0+

Chicago burbs

Discussion Starter
• Sep 5, 2006

• #37

cgar_smoker87 said:

Here are my favorites in this order:

CAO Italia
Aston VSG
Rocky Patel Sun Grown
MOnte Cristo Platinum
Playboy by Don Diego if I'm in the mood for something mild
St. Luis Rey if poor!

Click to expand...

Oh no! More stogies to add to my list :lol:

I've smoked nearly every one from my original list. And so far, no disappointments.

I have had several RP Sun Growns. An excellent cigar no doubt. As a matter of fact, the Sun Grown was the first RP cigar I ever had.

 

A

Alex Svenson

Joined Dec 2004

1K Posts | 0+

Chicago

• Sep 6, 2006

• #38

Since everyone else is listing 5, I will too. However, these are not my favorites per say, just a list of must smokes if you want to try something very very unique:

5 Vegas Limitada 06
Camacho Diploma
Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ
Cusano C10
Fuente OpusX