I too prefer a bigger cigar, but usually don't have the time to devote an hour to anything besides yard work - so that is when I do most of my smoking.
Like Motion said, I keep a variety of smokes around, and just pick one to suit my mood at the time. There you go!! 8) 8)
I usually stick to a 50 ring or smaller, sometimes 52....My favorite ring is a 44, 6"-7" Partagas 8-9-8, RyJ Cazadores are some of my current favorites....
It really all depends on my mood and time of day, and how much time I have.....
I think my all time favorite size is a 7 or 7.5 x 42 or 44. But it varies every day!
I guess it really depends on the cigar. In general, I prefer robustos and torpedoes. It's just so much easier to cut a torpedo. My favorite torpedo is probably the 5 Vegas followed by the 5 Vegas Alpha. You can't beat a Cohiba Esplindido for a churchill though.
After reading this thread the first time, I decided to tackle the IT Cameroon monster that I recieved quite some time ago in a PIF package, and have decided that 52 or 53 is about the biggest I want to smoke. That 60 guage cigar was great, but it was just too big for me.