Ahh the age old debate! I cannot stay away any longer! Sailors smoke could have been a miriad of diffferent things, and we all know it, could have been wet, could have been old, could have been a humid day when he smoked it, it could have been 10000000 other things. The fact of the matter is, this is why this issue will never die. You have some who say a $5 cuban kicks the domestics noses in the dirt and you have others saying there are domestics that are just as good, but don't mention price. I will not instigate by saying there are no domestics that will compete nose to nose for the same US dollar amount, but I will say that I have smoked cubans that drew terrible, that were plugged and all that crap, but! what I will say is, those were the best 1/8" 's of a cigar I ever smoked!!
Domestics win hands down for construction, but I agree with CC A PAM or hell even a Bolivar regente for that matter make a hell of a great smoke!
I will have to try the CC challenge on smoking nothing but cubans for a month or two, I've heard the same reviews from other boards on the topic.
Enjoy all, and keep the opinions flowing!! It's the beautiful thing about our hobby, so many different choices for so many different palates, but I can still enjoy smoking a fine cigar with anyone who enjoys the same hobby! 8)
Regards,
Paul