Nicarao, etc.

Joined Sep 2005
847 Posts | 0+
Newport, RI
Has anyone tried any of the Nicarao cigars? I know Vince has mentioned them from time to time. I am currently wavering between medium and full-bodied cigars in preferences and these seem closer to full. They're a pretty good price and since I bought that Vicksburg humidor, I can actually buy in bulk now.

While I have your attention...I have a couple more questions for the audience.

I nearly always buy singles when I get cigars and even the couple of boxes I've bought, I rarely smoke the same cigar two days in a row. I heard somewhere that it is good for developing the palette to smoke the same cigar at least a few days in a row in order to get the subtle notes of that type of cigar. This would then help when trying other types of cigars. Being a relatively new cigar smoker, this sounds interesting. Any thoughts?

And finally, speaking of the Vicksburg, I got it a week ago, and it looks great and I really want to get it full of cigars. The instructions had a method of seasoning the humidor that I had never heard of. You place a dish if distilled water in the humidor and let it sit for at least three days (makes sense). Then let the humidor come up to 80% (!?!). At this point, remove the bowl of water and install your humidifier and let the humidity come back down to 75% and then gradually fill the humidor (1/4 full, wait 2-3 days and repeat). I've let the humidor season for a week and gotten it from about 65% to 72%. I'm willing to be patient since it's a relatively large humidor, but at this rate, it'll be Christmas before I can put cigars in it! Should I be worried about the humidor? The instructions don't mention a time frame to reach 80%, but I would think it'd be done by now. I know the hygrometer's good because I cross-checked it with my calibrated one in the other humidor. I'm thinking of removing the water and putting in the cigars now. Should I wait a few days and I'm just being impatient? I can't buy any more cigars until then since my other humidor is REALLY full. It is South Carolina and I think the HOUSE is currently at 65% humidity, but still...

Wow, this ended up being a long post. Thanks for hanging on this long. :wink:
 
OK, I tried ONE Nicaro, and that was more than enough for me...I am not a fan. Your results may vary.
Yes, it is a great idea to buy in multiples, and give the cigar a chance. You will need to be a bit selective however, so you don't end up like me in my statement above.
I still like to wipe down the inside of a new humi with distilled water, I know, it can crack, cause polar shift, and all that... :wink:
But, I have had it work well for me, if it ain't broke....

Now, go and smoke something and stop worrying!

:D
 
I am sure HighPsi will speak up but there is a lot of wood in that Humi that needs to soak up water.
 
I Love the Nicaro corona in the morning, it has replaced my Don Carlos III for my Morning smoke ,great with coffee after breakfast.
If you like something a little on the lighter side try the
Cacique Maimi ( Ka-seek) from Tabacaleria Tropical. , the smallest size is the robusto.
Enjoy, Vince
 
Never had the Nicaro so no help there.

As to the seasoning, put in the largest container or water you can. The more surface area, the better. If you absolutely have to, you can get a spray bottle and set it to mist. You want an actual mist and not a spray with any droplets. Do it very lightly a few times a day if you have to but not enough to really dampen the wood. I got a spot of mold on mine that I had to sand down because I got it too wet, so don't over do it.

I've seen the 80% and done the 80% thing as well and think its a good idea. If you can hold it there, you won't have any problems holding it at your desired RH.
 
acharpe said:
I nearly always buy singles when I get cigars and even the couple of boxes I've bought, I rarely smoke the same cigar two days in a row. I heard somewhere that it is good for developing the palette to smoke the same cigar at least a few days in a row in order to get the subtle notes of that type of cigar. This would then help when trying other types of cigars. Being a relatively new cigar smoker, this sounds interesting. Any thoughts?


actually just the opposite is true in my opinion. here is why i think that.

ever go to a real fancy dinned and inbetween courses they give you a little semisweet candy to "clense the palate"?

this is done because your taste buds work best when there is a drastic change in flavor. in other words the more the flavor differs the more you taste it.

try it out.
get an ice cream cone. (not a sugar cone) dont put ice cream in it. eat that about 2 minutes before you eat a steak that has some salt on it. the steak will taste better.

or ... a better example. chocolate covered pretzles. the salt and the sweet are great together because they are so far appart from one another.

and my favorite example: Drink OJ while eating pizsza. the spice and salt of the pizza will make the cool and sweet of the OJ stand out and vice versa. it sounds gross but it isnt trust me on this one.


would i lead you astray?

i would say wait a day or two before smoking another. take notes and come pare from time to time. that will help you understand the little differences. ... better yet do that with all your cigars.
 
Barcochris said:
I am sure HighPsi will speak up but there is a lot of wood in that Humi that needs to soak up water.

Holy crap,,, wrong thread..... PWI
 
I don't think that consecutively smoking a cigar will help you improve your palate directly but as you said it would allow you to pick up on certain nuances and then apply them to others. For instance you smoke a nicaruaguan puro then a nicarauguan with a Sumatran wrapper. You do that enough times and you'll see what that does for the cigar in terms of flavor.

One of the best things IMO is to get acquainted with the different flavors. Be watchful of reviews and then compare notes. Keep doing it until you get it down. Just remember not do do this with cA--not everyone will get pencil lead. :lol:
 
acharpe-

im sure it will take quite some time to get the humi to where it needs to be...i got my vicksburg seasonned real quick though as when i got mine it was real dry out and we were running a humidifier in the bedroom. So i had a bright idea- i took the for trays and sat them on top of where the humidifier emits humidity for a few hours... then i put them back in the humi and i took a towel and got it nice and damp and i layed it over the middle trays in the humi...i had the whole thing seasoned and ready to go in about two days or so, im also using a cigar oasis which helped speed things up since it would initially just run quite often to keep the humidity up where i wanted..

but i've also used the "wipe down the insides with a moist towel" method previously and it has worked for me with no issues...i think as long as you dont go crazy with how much water you wipe down with and how often, it should be fine...anyway, it will just take some patience
 
Barcochris said:
Barcochris said:
I am sure HighPsi will speak up but there is a lot of wood in that Humi that needs to soak up water.

Holy crap,,, wrong thread..... PWI


I guess it was the right thread,, I need to stop drinking when I post.
 
Barcochris said:
Barcochris said:
Barcochris said:
I am sure HighPsi will speak up but there is a lot of wood in that Humi that needs to soak up water.

Holy crap,,, wrong thread..... PWI


I guess it was the right thread,, I need to stop drinking when I post.

Please don't; its very entertaining.
 
Barcochris said:
I am here for your amusement.

lol, you confused the hell out of me chris, i was like "well, i guess i should chime in" then i was like "hunh, well maybe i shouldnt..." i had to read the orig post like 3 times and then i just figured you went crazy, haha
 
Thank you all for your help. I put in a larger bowl of water with more surface area in the bottom of the humidor and wiped down the inside lightly with DI water. (Had to - splashed a little when I put the bowl in) It's sitting at 79% now and should hit 80 soon.

As for the cigar tasting, definitely good tips, but kuzi16 got me really hungry with his post. :wink: