Blind Box Pass, the original

SA-WEEEET!

There are 13 unclaimed cigars left...there are approximately 14 (depending on Syntax) unidentified puts. My last put was a Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca, so either mine or one of DD's went missing. Oh well...the sheets almost balance. Fill in the gaps if you can.

dbrad4d's puts (20 of 20):
5 Vegas Limitada Torpedo
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature
Arturo Fuente Opus XXX "Power Ranger"
CAO 65th Anniversary Tonton
CAO Brazilia GOL
CAO L’Anniversaire Maduro Churchill
Camacho SLR Perfecto #1
Cohiba red dot robusto
Cuesta Rey Belicoso #1
Cusano C10 Crown Corona
Diploma
Gurkha Master's Select Connecticut Robusto
Juan Lopez Epicure No. 2
Juan Lopez Titania
La Unica Belicoso No. 3
Montecristo #2 Torpedo
Perdomo Estate Seleccion Monstro Maduro
Punch Rare Corojo Magnum
Sosa Torpedo
Victor Sinclair Series 55 Red Label Churchill

RedLeg0811's puts (4 of 4):
Diploma
Romeo Y Julieta
RP Edge Corojo Toro
RP Vintage 1992 Toro

axegod75's puts (5 of 5):
Bolivar Toro
Cusano C10 Corona
Diablo Picantes Robusto
Hemingway Short Story
Ramon Allones Churchill

DevilDog723's puts (6 1/2 of 7):
5 Vegas Torpedo
Ashton Classic Sovereign
CAO Gold Robusto
Camacho Diploma
Gurkha Masters Choice Toro
Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca
1/2 Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca

Brenda's puts (6 of 9):
Arturo Fuente Opus XXX "Power Ranger"
Cusano 18 Paired Maduro robusto
Gurkha Centurion
La Gloria Cubana Serie R #4
Montecristo Platinum Robusto
Partagas Black Label Clasico

FreedomGuns' puts (6 1/2 of 7):
Joya de Nicaragua Antano
Joya de Nicaragua Celebracion Consul
1/2 Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca
Perdomo Cuban Parejo Perfecto Grande Maduro
Perdomo Estate Seleccion Imperio
Rocky Patel 1992 Churchill
Trinidad Belicoso

Iminaquagmire's puts (6 of 7):
CAO Cameroon (Belicoso? Tapered end like a torpedo)
Flor de Juan Lopez (Epicure No 2?)
Montecristo Tubo
Rockey Patel Edge A
Rocky Patel Sungrown Toro
Torano Silver Exodus ’59 Corona Grande

Markus59's puts (3 of 5):
5 Vegas "A" Archetype
Camacho SLR Toro
Oliva Classic

Syntax's puts (1 of 6?):
Cohiba Red Dot (crystal corona?)

Capt's puts (3 of 5):
Hoyo De Monterrey October 2003
Perdomo 1991 Estate Imperio
Sosa Pyramid

Cybrus' puts (6 of 6):
CAO Black
Cusano 18 Robusto
La Gloria Cubana Serie R #5 Maduro
Partagas Black Label Robusto
Punch Gran Puro (either the Rancho or Santa Rita)
Punch Gran Puro

Bobberrific/Ahoffpsu's puts (6 of 6):
AF Flor Fina 8-5-8 natural (Bobberrific)
Carlos Torano Reserva Select Glass Tube (Bobberrific)
Punch Gran Puro Rancho (Bobberrific)
AF Flor Fina 8-5-8 natural (Ahoffpsu)
Carlos Torano Reserva Select (Ahoffpsu)
H. Upmann 1844 Monarch Tubo (Ahoffpsu)

Phisherman (4 of 4 plus 1 freebie):
AF Opus X Fuente Fuente
Camacho Bundle freebie
CAO Sopranos robusto
Diploma
Hemingway Masterpiece

Big Paintbrush (4 of 4):
Montecristo Platinum Robusto
Montecristo White Robusto
Partagas Serie P #2
5 Vegas ‘A’ Archetype

Wolfdaddy (5 of 5):
AF Flor Fina 8-5-8 Maduro
Armando Ramos Robaina
Ashton Aged Maduro #40
Ashton VSG Torpedo
Punch Gran Puro Rancho

Jhopephulle (6 of 6):
Indian Tabac Maduro its a super toro size
Joya de Nicarauga Celebracion Consul
Camacho Coyolar
Gurkha Genghis Khan Toro
Graycliff Professionale PGX
Edge Toro

unclaimed takes ( 13 ):
C10 Crown Corona
CAO Italia Gondola
Flor de Bauza
H. Upmann (robusto in ziploc bag in envelope)
Hoyo Dark Sumatra Ebano
La Unica #200
Montecristo Platinum Toro
Montecristo White Rothchilde
Montesino Belicoso
Punch Rare Corojo Magnum
RP Vintage 1990 Robusto
Reo Robusto
Sancho Panza

i think i put in
indian tabac maduro its a super toro size
joya de nicarauga celebracion
camacho coyolar
gurkha gengis khan
graycliff
edge

i need to remember what i put in next time

I would not have put in a CAO Cameroon. I said what I did because it sounded like an Edge Lite and as far as I know, I'm the only one that had any to put into the box.

Sorry about that Quag. I'll fix it in the next list after some more folks chime in.

FreedomGuns said:

DevilDog723's puts (6 1/2 of 7):

"1/2" Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca

Click to expand...

Huh?

SmokePole said:

Leeroy_Fan said:

I am having a brain fart right now, im sorry guys. A Qban is wat again. Plz remind me.

Click to expand...

Say it out loud, you'll understand.

Click to expand...

oh haha, i wasnt paying attention, prounouncing different hahaha

DevilDog723 said:

Huh?

Click to expand...

I 'put' a Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca. There was no Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca in the box when it got to dbrad4d. I have know way of knowing whose put is unaccounted for so I attributed 1/2 to you and 1/2 to me.

FreedomGuns said:

There are 13 unclaimed cigars left...there are approximately 14 (depending on Syntax) unidentified puts. My last put was a Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarca, so either mine or one of DD's went missing. Oh well...the sheets almost balance. Fill in the gaps if you can.

Click to expand...

I thought I wrote down what I sent Capt but, can't find the list. I really like the idea of putting a Post-it with our name along with the cigar. Can we do that with the next pass?

dbrad4d said:

On the upcoming pass you will post your takes and puts when you make them. We will be able to keep a running inventory with each stop.

Click to expand...

But, wont that that the mystery out of it?

It will be a regular box pass this time, not a blind. I kinda like the idea better as there are a bunch of stix that I know I would like to try and would be able to pin point them.

phisherman said:

It will be a regular box pass this time, not a blind.

Click to expand...

I'd prefer a Blind Pass only because folks can't pick out all of the good stuff.

If I put an Opus I'd like the last guy on the pass to have just as much a chance of getting it as the guy after me.

its equal value tho. if you take a high end cigar you must put a cigar of equal or higher value in. that way everyone can get a nice selection to choose from and if you do not have any high end cigars you can just take a cigar that you can match in value.

Its tough when you put in a rare cigar like an Opus X. You can find a cigar of equal Value for MSRP, but its much easier to get that cigar. That is one of the labels I will just avoid in the pass. You cannot replace it that easy unless you put in another Opus X or Padron 1926 or anejo. There are so many good cigars out there to try and to pass. I will stick with those.

Can we also make a rule that you have to put the MSRP (or cigar.com price) on your puts so that peole can put in something of equal or lesser value to replace it. I would feel bad if I picked out a 10 dollar stick thinking that it was only a 5 dollar stick and putting something in that did not replace it monetarily.

its in the rules on page 40 of this thread about the prices and what to use as a guide and if in doubt just ask for help someone will always help out

phisherman said:

Can we also make a rule that you have to put the MSRP (or cigar.com price) on your puts so that peole can put in something of equal or lesser value to replace it. I would feel bad if I picked out a 10 dollar stick thinking that it was only a 5 dollar stick and putting something in that did not replace it monetarily.

Click to expand...

I like this idea. I know I'll be making my selections at home. My problem is I don't have internet connection at home. So, I like the idea of putting a Post-it with the Cigar.com price on your stick.

How 'bout say if I put in a Davidoff. Which, unless I missed it, c.com doesn't carry. How about I just leave the price tag on? I've noticed prices vary on these from site to site, and my local shop has some varieties for quite a bit less than any site sells them for.